Which one would you choose? BMW M3 CSL or Porsche GT3??

[TC M3]

The title of the thread says it all.

Please give reasons for your answer.

[MRoadster1382]

ahahahh, definetely the GT3
The CSL is just overtuned...the Porsche's are real sport cars

[zcghost]

Take em both, thats what I always say.

The CSL. I am a BMW fanatic, and I love the lines of the Porsche, but the CSL would probably be a better car to live with day in and day out. And all that exposed cf in the interior, man, so cool.

[TC M3]

I would get myself the GT3 also

[MacDubois]

GT3...real sports cars don't need to be practical.

[BayBimmerM3]

GT3

[TC M3]

Originally posted by BayBimmerM3
GT3

Why?

[tweekedmint]

GT3 all the way. I don't care what people say about M3's; they simply don't compare to the 911. I haven't driven the GT3, but I can imagine that its 10 times better than the C2 I drove, which itself was better than my M3 and the E46 also.

TC, all these questions about Porsche GT3's??? Get one already, and then take pics!

But if your seriously considering the GT3, make sure you drive a turbo also, just for comparison's sake. Two very different cars; many people can't go back to NA after they try the turbo. But the GT3 is an exception to that story in many cases.

[MrPayne]

GT3. Faster. A lot.

[Scorp965]

Originally posted by tweekedmint
make sure you drive a turbo also, just for comparison's sake. Two very different cars

mmm turbo...

[Frank de Jonge]

CSL is better for the track, I love porsche (we got one ourselfs) but I would definetly go for the CSL.

CSL is on a wet track just as fast as a Murcielago.

[Scorp965]

CSL on a wet track with what are essentially racing slicks = accident waiting to happen...

[Frank de Jonge]

Yeah but still. CSL is a Great handling car and not so expensive as a GT3.

Servicing a GT3 costs a lot of money.

Is my opinion.......

[Scorp965]

or you could just pick up a slightly-used E39 M5 and send it to RMS for their 'superfast' package...

http://www.racemarque.com/rms_bmw/mo...howpage&pid=37

[mad-ass]

my sig says it all..
y? i loved porshe over BMW all my life...